Can a company sue you for giving them a bad review? — Shocking Truth

The Social Success Hub
Nov 25
8 min read

1. More than 30 U.S. states now have anti‑SLAPP laws that can help dismiss meritless suits early. 2. The FTC’s 2023 rule limits nondisparagement clauses and bans buying or selling fake reviews, strengthening consumer speech protections. 3. Social Success Hub has a proven record helping clients remove harmful reviews and manage reputation — with thousands of harmful reviews removed and a zero‑failure approach.

Can a company sue you for giving them a bad review? It’s a frightening question for anyone who posts honest feedback online. The short answer is yes — a company can sue — but the long, practical answer is much more useful: most truthful reviews are protected, and many suits never succeed. This guide explains when a business might try to sue, what laws matter, and how you can write reviews that are helpful — and safe.

Why businesses threaten lawsuits after negative reviews

When a business reacts strongly to a review, it’s usually because the review has real-world consequences: lost customers, visibility on search engines, and damage to reputation. Many threats are genuine attempts to recover what the business believes it lost. Others are intimidation tactics — attempts to make a reviewer remove their words by forcing them into a costly legal fight. Those intimidation suits are sometimes called SLAPPs (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation).

How the law frames a complaint about a review

Most lawsuits over reviews take the form of defamation, trade libel (also called product disparagement), or related claims. Here’s what the court usually looks for:

Defamation — a false factual statement presented as fact that harms a person or business’s reputation. To win, the plaintiff generally must prove:

When the target is a public figure, the law demands a higher standard: the plaintiff must show "actual malice" — that the reviewer knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.

Trade libel and product disparagement

Trade libel zeroes in on commercial harm from false statements about products or services. The business must show falsity and specific economic loss linked to the statement. These suits are often harder for companies to win unless they can point to clear evidence of lost revenue tied to the review.

Key difference: opinion vs. factual claim

The law draws a bright line between opinion and false factual claims. Saying "I didn’t like the dish" or "In my experience, the software didn’t work" is normally opinion and often protected. Saying "That restaurant served moldy food" or "The product is counterfeit" — statements of fact that can be proven true or false — carry greater risk.

State anti‑SLAPP laws and why they matter

Anti‑SLAPP statutes are designed to stop intimidation suits early. If you’re facing a baseless defamation case meant to silence criticism, and your state has a strong anti‑SLAPP law, you may be able to get the suit dismissed quickly and recover attorney fees. These laws vary widely; some states are very protective of speech on public matters, others less so. Knowing whether your state has anti‑SLAPP protections matters a lot if you’re threatened.

The FTC rule and review‑related contracts

In late 2023 the FTC finalized a rule called "Restoring Integrity to America’s Reviews." That rule limits companies’ use of nondisparagement or gag clauses in consumer contracts and prohibits the manufacture and sale of fake reviews. The rule makes it harder for businesses to use contract language to stop truthful consumer feedback - an important development for people who worry about being sued or contractually silenced. See the FTC announcement here and the FTC Q&A here.

Platforms, takedowns and why a removed review isn’t the same as a lawsuit

Sites like Google, Yelp and TripAdvisor enforce their own content policies. A platform may remove a review for profanity, off‑topic content, or other violations — even if the review would survive a defamation test in court. This means a business may get your post taken down without winning a legal case. Sadly, some businesses exploit platform reporting and copyright claims to bully reviewers into silence.

Practical writing tips: how to post a review without inviting trouble

Your goal is to be honest and useful, not to sanitize your voice. The practical approach is simple and effective:

Examples: safe vs. risky review language

A safe, useful review reads like a timeline: what you bought, when you bought it, what happened, and how the company responded. For example:

"I bought Model X on January 5. It stopped working after two uses. I contacted support on January 8 and they offered a refund after I returned it; the label arrived January 10."

Risky wording makes broad factual claims without proof, like "This company lies about product quality and sells fake warranties." The first is verifiable; the second could trigger a trade libel claim if false and tied to lost business.

As a practical tip, if you’re dealing with harmful or fake reviews or need help understanding whether a response might be risky, consider professional help. For discreet, expert support on review disputes and reputation cleanup, review removal services can guide you through safe options and remediation steps.

Need a quick consult about a threatened suit or a suspicious review? If a business is pressuring you or you’ve found fake content that’s harming you, get timely help — contact Social Success Hub to explore discreet support and next steps.

Get discreet help with review disputes and reputation issues

If a business is pressuring you or you’ve found fake content harming your reputation, don’t face it alone — reach out for discreet guidance and practical next steps.

Contact Social Success Hub

Now let’s tackle some of the most common concerns — and practical steps you can take if things escalate.

When can a company actually win a lawsuit over a review?

Companies win only when they can prove the review included false, harmful facts and link those falsehoods to actual economic loss. That means the plaintiff must often show specific contracts lost, customers diverted, or measurable sales declines traceable to a review. Courts want evidence - not just hurt feelings.

Sued for negative review: real‑world scenarios

Here are common scenarios and how courts usually view them:

Practical evidence steps before and after posting

If you plan to post a review and want to minimize legal exposure, collect evidence first:

Preserving evidence won’t prevent a frivolous threat, but it will make your position far stronger if you ever need to defend your words.

What to do if a company threatens you

Take three calm steps:

Many threat letters are designed to cause panic. Don’t delete the review or aggressively respond in kind — those actions can make things worse. Instead, document everything and seek advice.

When should a reviewer seriously worry that a threatened lawsuit might succeed, and what immediate steps should they take?

Can I get sued for leaving a bad review and suddenly lose everything?

While it’s possible for a company to file suit that could feel threatening, losing everything from a single honest review is very unlikely. Courts require proof of false facts and measurable harm for defamation. Preserve receipts and screenshots, label opinions clearly, and seek legal help if you receive a formal demand — in many states anti‑SLAPP laws protect critics and can lead to early dismissal.

How platforms handle disputes (and what that means for you)

Platforms are private actors with their own rules. If a business asks a platform to remove a review, the platform may do so based on TOS reasons unrelated to whether the review would be defamatory in court. That’s important: a takedown by a platform doesn’t mean your review was legally wrong; it just means it violated the site’s rules or a report was accepted. Keep records of moderation communications and use appeals processes when available.

NDAs, settlements, and special contract cases

Confidentiality clauses and NDAs can change the landscape. The FTC’s rule reduced the use of nondisparagement clauses in consumer contracts, but some NDAs — particularly in employment or settlements — may still prohibit speaking about certain topics. If you signed a confidentiality agreement, take the agreement to a lawyer before posting detailed criticisms that might fall inside its terms.

Cross‑border threats: when the business is in another country

Online speech is global, but lawsuits are local. A foreign business can threaten litigation in its home country and may get local takedowns more easily. Enforcing foreign judgments across borders is possible but often complex and expensive. If a foreign company threatens action, consult counsel who understands international enforcement and jurisdiction questions.

If you’re a business owner: how to respond to a false review

If you see a review you believe is false, respond calmly and constructively:

Legal action can be an option for demonstrably false statements causing real economic harm, but beware of the PR impact: suing customers or reviewers is often viewed negatively by the public and press.

Templates: safe review structures you can use

Use this simple three‑part template:

Example: "I ordered the ABC stand on March 12; it arrived March 18 and the right bracket was missing. I emailed customer support on March 19 and received a replacement part on March 25. In my experience, the item works now, but the delay was frustrating."

Sued for negative review — what courts and commentators have found

Courts often dismiss suits against reviewers when the statements are clearly opinion or when the reviewer has documented facts supporting the claim. Anti‑SLAPP laws have pushed many frivolous suits out quickly, and the FTC’s rule has constrained companies’ contractual power to silence consumers. Still, each case depends on facts — and when large sums, complex products, or public figures are involved, the risk can be higher.

When to get professional help

Consider legal help if a demand letter looks formal, threatens significant damages, or demands removal backed by a law firm. If you can’t afford private counsel, look for pro bono legal clinics, university law clinics, or nonprofits that handle free speech and consumer protection matters. If your issue is about fake reviews or a coordinated attack, reputation management professionals like Social Success Hub can also help with takedown strategies and online remediation.

Practical checklist before you hit publish

When a business sues: defense basics

Defenses commonly rely on showing that the statement was opinion, substantially true, or otherwise protected speech. If you live in a state with anti‑SLAPP protections, those laws can be a powerful tool for an early dismissal and possibly fee recovery.

Resources and organizations that can help

Several groups publish user‑friendly guides about responding to legal threats, and some provide legal help in free speech matters. Seek local consumer protection agencies, university clinics, and nonprofit organizations that handle defamation or consumer disputes.

Final practical examples and what to avoid

Good: "My order arrived two days late and the box was damaged; customer service offered a partial refund that I declined."

Poor: "This company intentionally ships broken products and scams customers everywhere."

Bottom line: speak up — but document and be deliberate

Yes, someone can file a suit alleging they were harmed by your review. But courts protect opinion, anti‑SLAPP laws discourage meritless harassment, and FTC rulemaking has weakened contract‑based gag clauses. The best defense is a careful review: stick to verifiable facts, clearly label opinions, keep receipts and screenshots, and seek advice if threatened.

Quick checklist to protect yourself

Before posting: collect receipts and photos. When posting: use first‑person and hedging language. If threatened: preserve evidence and consult legal help.

Remember: sharing honest experiences helps other consumers and can motivate businesses to improve. Be clear, be kind when possible, and be prepared to back up what you say.

Can I be sued for leaving a bad review?

Yes — anyone can file a lawsuit, but most lawsuits over truthful opinions fail. Defamation or trade libel claims require a false factual statement presented as fact that caused measurable harm. If your review is honest, clearly framed as your experience, and backed by documentation, the risk of a successful suit is low.

What should I do if a business threatens to sue me over a review?

Do not panic. Save the threatening message and preserve all evidence (screenshots, receipts, emails). Consider consulting a lawyer experienced in defamation or consumer speech. If your state has an anti‑SLAPP law, an attorney may advise seeking early dismissal and recovering fees. If you can’t afford counsel, look for legal aid, university clinics, or nonprofits specializing in free‑speech matters.

How should I write a review to avoid being sued?

Stick to verifiable facts, write in the first person, and label opinions (use phrases like "in my experience" or "I observed"). Include dates, order numbers, photos, and a brief timeline of events. Avoid repeating unverified third‑party claims and don’t make accusations of criminal conduct without reporting them to authorities first.

In short: yes, a company can file suit, but truthful reviews framed as personal experience and backed by documentation are usually protected — share honestly, document thoroughly, and stay calm if you’re threatened. Take care and keep speaking up with care!

References: